Planners vs. Spontaneous People: Honest Thoughts from a Planner

Published 4-7-19. Updated 3-25-23.

Planners vs. spontaneous people. Like oil and water, those that like to plan their schedules in advance and those who operate with nothing but spontaneity don’t mix well, at least under natural circumstances.

Planners, of which I am one, like to know what is coming up in the week or month ahead. While I obviously can’t speak for all planners, I like to carefully arrange my schedule around the fixed commitments I have each week.

Inside the mind of a planner 

I have certain evenings of the week that are spoken for. Of the two or three that are taken, date night is flexible, able to be moved to a different night to accommodate things that come up, but by default, it is Friday or Saturday night.

With the remaining evenings and weekends available, I plug things in like chores, hobbies, get-togethers with friends and family, catching up on overflow work, etc.

As I’ve gotten older, I’ve realized that I need recovery time between events. Thus, I no longer pack every evening after work with an outing like I used to.

I’ve also found that if I’m not careful, my calendar gets fuller than I intended in a big hurry. So I have to be selective about the things I say yes to if I want to keep from getting myself overloaded.

Something I don’t always do, but have found is most helpful, is keeping one or two unscheduled evenings per week to relax or catch up on projects with which I am inevitably falling behind. These nights have become more necessary over time, considering my regularly scheduled activities. I’ve come to rely on them, and without at least one in a week, I feel tense and overloaded, even if my packed week is all things that I enjoy.

In short, I like to know my plans for the upcoming week early so I can work in the unscheduled stuff around them. It helps keep me sane. Enter the spontaneous person …

Thinking like a spontaneous person

I can’t say for sure, but here are my guesses on how a spontaneous person operates.

  • They take great delight in having the ability to be flexible and seize great opportunities when they come up last minute.
  • They hesitate to plan ahead because something more appealing might come along in the time slot already committed to something else.
  • They may be slow to sign up for anything that requires a regular time in their schedule. Something unforeseen could always come up, and put them in a bind, unable to attend to that which is more desirable.If you are a spontaneous person, I welcome your edits and additions to this.

Planners vs. spontaneous people: when the two worlds collide

My husband is a naturally spontaneous person. Between marrying a planner and the realization that some outings need to be arranged in advance for optimum results, he has become more likely to plan since we’ve been married. (Yesssss!)

We’ve been blessed to have multiple dear friends who are almost 100% spontaneous. This could be highly problematic under certain circumstances. See my explanation above about preferring to plan my week in advance.

When last-minute invitations for things ranging from dinner, sporting events and even camping trips come through, it has the potential to get me ruffled. The selfish part of me thinks, “But, but … I had such and such planned! How about 24-48 hours’ notice? Please?”

But when I step back from my control freak episode, I am usually able to think more clearly and

1) recognize and appreciate that people I care about want to spend time with me; and
2) evaluate what in my schedule can be rearranged to accommodate last-minute invitations.

By the grace of God, I am learning that people are more valuable than to-dos, so I can put that into practice by saying “yes” with little notice, if I can, when control freak me would rather say “no.”

But the unfortunate reality of being planners amidst so many impromptu types is that we do have to turn them down a fair amount when they spring a fun idea with no notice on a night that has already been spoken for.

As an aside, planning and preparing go hand-in-hand for me.

If I am invited to do something for which I am not prepared, I am prone to resist.

For example, if I get an invite on a Thursday night to go camping that weekend, but I know that I don’t have camping food in stock, and maybe the gear needs some TLC, plus I had already set aside Thursday night to get “X, Y, and Z” done, I am going resist and probably turn you down.

As much as I would love to jump on any opportunity to go camping, I had already planned my Thursday night. Truthfully, the things I intended to work on are probably overdue.

So when I am put in the position of doing those things or running to the store to get items for camping and frenziedly packing, putting those tasks off and claiming my weekend, I hit a crisis and am apt to say no.

Oddly enough, the same invitation given just two days earlier could make a big difference. With a couple of days’ lead time, I can add camping items to my shopping list (for when I grocery shop Wednesday night at 9:30 p.m. every week – see I’m a planner), move things around accordingly and make it happen – if at all possible.

When it comes to planners vs. spontaneous people, I’ll offer a few points of advice to both types.

Advice for spontaneous people with planner friends

I imagine you cherish spontaneity as much as we cherish planning ahead, and that is OK.

  • If you recognize that some of your friends often have plans already when you make a same-day invite, try giving them a one, two, or multi-day notice once in a while. You might find that you’ll have a higher success rate.
  • If your friends turn you down, don’t be discouraged. Keep inviting. It’s likely that they would love to join you if they could and will take you up with the right timing.

Advice for planners with impromptu friends

I covered two main points above so I won’t repeat them here. Additionally:

  • Be flexible when you are able.
  • Honestly evaluate if your schedule is too rigid or self-serving. (E.g. you have too much going on, are unable or unwilling to make accommodations, or you are binge-watching a show and don’t want to be interrupted.)


God wired us all differently, and those differences add life-enriching variety.

I firmly believe we are better off when we surround ourselves with people who think and behave differently than we are naturally inclined. It helps give our personalities and character more depth. So regardless of which camp you find yourself in, I hope you’ll embrace your natural tendencies while being willing to accommodate those who do things differently.

Are you a planner or a spontaneous person?

I’d love to hear your thoughts on this topic or any ideas I didn’t think of for how to interact with the other type.

To get more content like this delivered straight to your inbox, subscribe here to get hooked up! Don’t worry, you won’t get spammed. I currently post 1-2 times per month.


5 responses to “Planners vs. Spontaneous People: Honest Thoughts from a Planner”

  1. Thanks for sharing! I’m a spontaneous person but am slightly becoming more of a planner.

    1. Summer Sorensen Avatar
      Summer Sorensen

      Nice. I don’t think there is one that is inherently better than another, for the record. I just wanted to share my perspective.

  2. […] Parting words of advice for extroverts and introverts (which overlaps to some degree with planners and spontaneous people – my post about that is here) […]

  3. Ivette Daggett Avatar
    Ivette Daggett

    I like this info. Thank you. I n a planner. my husband is spontaneous person. Lol.

    1. Summer Sorensen Avatar
      Summer Sorensen

      Oh wow that sounds like it could be a tough combo, lol. Hopefully, you guys have figured out how to make it work. Thank you for reading and commenting!

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: